In my search for info about the Kindle’s default typeface, I came across this little tirade. From the Comments:
I have earned my living making books for 40 years. I started by hand-setting metal type, moved on to machine-set metal type, then to printing books letterpress. Then to proofreading, copy editing, designing books, typesetting on a computer, managing book production.
I do not like gadgets: no iPod, no blackberry, no cell phone, hell, not even a microwave oven.
I’m exactly the sort of person the world expects to share Kidd’s opposition to electronic readers.
Plus: I have been an avid reader of books for, oh, 58 years.
I eagerly await that day there’s a really good electronic device with a vast library of text available, that is well designed, that has a good feel in the hand, that has a good screen, and (since I’m a typographer) that has a good choice of typefaces. & is not too expensive.
I’m not seeing it yet. Will I see it in my lifetime? Probably. I hope so. It remains to be seen if I’ll be able to overcome my gadget aversion and to expand my love of printed books to include this device.
But I’m eager and I’m hopeful. Bring it on!
There is no graphic design opportunity, partly because the Kindle’s first release has one typeface, one leading, one layout. I’ve seen people looking at ragged right type, but it was justified with oceans of white space between words in everything I viewed.
“PEOPLE DON’T WANT TO READ BOOKS ON A SCREEN.”
You hope.
Unless you’re a book designer, I’m not sure you really care about the typeface of the book you’re reading unless it somehow interferes with your, y’know, reading. I don’t, anyway. All this anti-Kindle book fetishism is bewildering to me. I love papercuts and cardboard boxes full of old paperbacks as much as anybody, but I can’t wait to try this thing. Having the amazingly deep backlist of somebody like Donald Westlake right at my fingertips, for example, that’s just amazing to me.
The Kindle is back-ordered until after Christmas, presumably because nobody wants to read books on a screen. Well, here’s a FAQ for anybody who’s on the fence…
The reason book designers care about the typeface is because they know it affects the reading experience. Duh. If you were a book designer you’d know that.
It’s getting tiring and annoying to refute all the misinformation about the Kindle, an imperfect 1st gen product but a ground-breaking, remarkable, undeniably useful product. Too many of the people criticizing the Kindle have never touched one and/or aren’t avid book readers.
If you like to read lengthy hardcover books, the Kindle offers many advantages (weight savings, cost savings, acquisition time savings). If you want to follow up references in a book to get more info online, without even getting up off the couch, Kindle is cool. If you want to take notes and flag passages in a book in a file that you can actually move onto your computer and reference later, Kindle works great. If you want to carry the book store with you wherever you go, go with Kindle. If you want an ebook device that fades into the background as you read for hours and become engrossed in the story, Kindle is your man.
On the other hand, if it’s actually the typeface that makes Moby Dick or Pride and Prejudice or The Adventures of Kavalier and Clay so good, the Kindle is not for you.
No, shit-wit. It’s not the typeface that makes them great. It’s the typeface that makes it more enjoyable to read great works. Or it’s the typeface (when it’s the wrong one for the job) that turns you off and you end up missing out on great literature because reading it gave you migraines.
More kindle-grumbling here:
5) Another negative: I miss book design. I like the work of typographers and cover artists and the other people involved in how commercial books look. On the Kindle, everything appears in the same typeface; covers are often reproduced poorly. This uniformity could become a bit boring over time. My guess, however, is as the technology improves, so will the publishers’ ability to present the texts as they would like.
This Kindle review has some telling info:
All published content appears in a modern serif font called Linotype Caecilia. System menus and message are in Sans-Serif Helvetica. The books don’t seem to use the publisher/author-specified fonts or typefaces and always appear in Caecilia. I purchased A Whole New Mind by Dan Pink, and an example in the book asks the reader to identify, Times New Roman, Arial and Courier. On the Kindle, all appear in exactly the same Caecilia type.